The Otterbox for the Torch is definitely a rip off no matter what the price (and particularly at $40 -- what an outrage). People here should be warned off buying it before it's too late.
I'm generally "gentle" with my BlackBerry devices, but got the Otterbox Commuter for "just in case" protection.
I was actually surprised the front bezel stayed attached on mine as long as it did, because as soon as I put it on I thought, "Oh, this is never gonna stay put..."
But after using it for just over 1 week, the bezel snapped from a 10-inch fall onto hardwood floor.