Ha you can't posts links yet so we can not see pics sorry. The chrome case mate I got was scratched up and then it scratched up my device when it was on it.
I would say keep the iSkin case, it protects more of the phone, and like Threefive says, you may run the risk of scratching your phone just putting on and taking off the casemate case. Plus IMO the iSkin just looks a lot better.