Originally Posted by
p1800nut Well, to get back on topic, I received my refurb Q10 today, a day earlier than promised. As I've recounted in the T-Mobile sub-forum, I had no luck Friday night at a local store (I could have ordered a new Q10, but not a refurb; I didn't ask about a Z10 because I already have one). So I skeptically followed the salesman's advice to try calling Customer Care. At first he said the program only included new phones, but when I politely but firmly reminded him that the CMO's newsletter said it was good for any phone T-Mobile sells, he cheerfully agreed. They billed me for the price of the phone, provided free expedited shipping, and applied an immediate $50 credit. The phone included a postage-paid envelope to return my functioning but ancient Curve 8330 for a $200 credit sometime in the next 2-3 billing cycles.
So, it's not a sham or a fake, though it seems to have been rolled out extremely roughly. My experience was that both the local store and the Customer Care agent were sort of aware of the program, though they had to read up on it. (Keep in mind this was the first day of the program.) In neither case did I get ANY pressure at all to consider a different phone. So my personal experience was very professional and I'm the very happy owner of a looks-like-new refurbished Q10. I'm really sorry that so many others seemed to have different experiences, but I get the the impression that it's due to a rough roll-out, not bad faith. (To be fair, it was not like it was planned in advance--Legere pretty much winged it on this, and maybe the details weren't thought out as well as they might have been.)