Which is faster? 1xev or Edge?
- 1XEV is kinda like 3G for cdma phones and 3G is usually shown on gsm phones. So which would be faster between 1xev and edge?
Posted from my CrackBerry at wapforums.crackberry.com08-30-09 10:48 AMLike 0 -
- well actually the comparison is was not 1X but 1xev, let me clarify. I'll list the different cell phone technologies from slowest to fasters.
CDMA: 1X >>> 1xev >>> 1XEV
GSM: edge >>> 3G
That being said is "1xev" faster than "edge"?08-30-09 09:35 PMLike 0 - Not sure you understand the way cdma works. When a phone says 1xev, it means that an EV data connections is available, but the phone is not connected to it. If it says 1XEV it means that you are connected to the EV network. They aren't different signals or speeds.08-30-09 09:49 PMLike 0
- Isn't 3G just 3rd generation and isn't 1xev/1XEV considered 3G? I always thought EDGE was the GSM version of 3G and 1XEV was the CDMA version of 3G. And where does EVDO fit into this is that the same as 1xev? I thought I understood this now I'm confused
Posted from my CrackBerry at wapforums.crackberry.com08-30-09 09:58 PMLike 0 -
-
This is correct. They are both different stages in the EVDO technology.
CDMA: 1X >>> 1xev >>> 1XEV
GSM: edge >>> 3G
That being said is "1xev" faster than "edge"?08-30-09 10:53 PMLike 0 - Anything lowercase means you are NOT connected to data.....1xev you have NOT connected.....
edge: not connected
1XEV connected at or near 3G speed
EDGE connected at or near 2.5 2.75 G
I'm 100% sure of these facts
Posted from my CrackBerry at wapforums.crackberry.com08-30-09 10:59 PMLike 0 - CDMA:
D - Voice Only
1x - Voice Only, no data
1X - Voice, Data(up to 144kbps)
1xev - Voice Only, no Data
1XEV - Voice, Data(3G speeds up to 3.1Mbps with Rev.A)
GSM:
GSM - Voice Only
gprs - Voice only, No data
GPRS - Voice, Data up to ~60kbps
edge - Voice Only, No data
EDGE - Voice, Data up to 450kbps(depending on device model, network conditions, average speeds are ~130kbps)
3G - Voice, Data(simultaneous) up to 7.2Mbps(theoretical)
You can receive 1XEV with both Rev.0 and Rev.A. Depends on the device and network equipment. Rev.A is much faster on upload then Rev.0.08-30-09 11:51 PMLike 0 - Ahhh ok, so the end result is EDGE is faster than 1xev? Is there a difference between edge and EDGE?
Posted from my CrackBerry at wapforums.crackberry.com08-31-09 08:44 AMLike 0 - EDGE is only faster the 1xev because 1xev means there is no data connection. 1xev is the same circumstance as edge (lower case).
Lower case = no data connection.
So saying EDGE is faster the 1xev is only true because the data connection is not active on the CDMA phone. edge is just as fast as 1xev since data is turned off on both. Using the same analogy, 1X and 1XEV are both faster than edge.
From a CDMAS to GSM standpoint. You have to look at upper-case lettering.
EDGE = 1X
3G = 1XEV08-31-09 09:08 AMLike 0 - CDMA:
D - Voice Only
1x - Voice Only, no data
1X - Voice, Data(up to 144kbps)
1xev - Voice Only, no Data
1XEV - Voice, Data(3G speeds up to 3.1Mbps with Rev.A)
GSM:
GSM - Voice Only
gprs - Voice only, No data
GPRS - Voice, Data up to ~60kbps
edge - Voice Only, No data
EDGE - Voice, Data up to 450kbps(depending on device model, network conditions, average speeds are ~130kbps)
3G - Voice, Data(simultaneous) up to 7.2Mbps(theoretical)
You can receive 1XEV with both Rev.0 and Rev.A. Depends on the device and network equipment. Rev.A is much faster on upload then Rev.0.08-31-09 10:33 AMLike 0 - EDGE is only faster the 1xev because 1xev means there is no data connection. 1xev is the same circumstance as edge (lower case).
Lower case = no data connection.
So saying EDGE is faster the 1xev is only true because the data connection is not active on the CDMA phone. edge is just as fast as 1xev since data is turned off on both. Using the same analogy, 1X and 1XEV are both faster than edge.
From a CDMAS to GSM standpoint. You have to look at upper-case lettering.
EDGE = 1X
3G = 1XEV
Exactly.....why are people putting out bad info......1xev is NO CONNECTION!!!!!!08-31-09 11:03 AMLike 0 -
Posted from my CrackBerry at wapforums.crackberry.com08-31-09 11:15 AMLike 0 -
Let me try to finish this thread after all.
Like other users have posted
CDMA:
D - Voice Only
1x - Voice Only, no data
1X - Voice, Data(up to 144kbps)
1xev - Voice Only, no Data
1XEV - Voice, Data(3G speeds up to 3.1Mbps with Rev.A)
GSM:
GSM - Voice Only
gprs - Voice only, No data
GPRS - Voice, Data up to ~60kbps
edge - Voice Only, No data
EDGE - Voice, Data up to 450kbps(depending on device model, network conditions, average speeds are ~130kbps)
3G - Voice, Data(simultaneous) up to 7.2Mbps(theoretical)
You can receive 1XEV with both Rev.0 and Rev.A. Depends on the device and network equipment. Rev.A is much faster on upload then Rev.0.
1X is at EDGE SPEEDS.
1XEV is at 3G SPEEDS (GSM) (for now, the GSM 3G version can still beat it.)
so 1X is slower then 3G.
When you see 1x, 1xev, edge, that means Voice is Avalible, data is not being used. If you where to connect to the browser in any of those situations you would most likely see them change to 1X, or 1XEV, or EDGE.
Now the 3G part, usually on phones 3G always shows up as I just posted it because it supports simultaneous Voice/ and Data at the same time. So that means they can both can be used, you can use both of them at the same time. Now some people have seen 3g on there phone which either means, 1. You blocked DATA usage on that line in the account, 2. Data is not available in your area, or 3. sometimes you just lost service and it's being weird... (you usually see the call failed messages after this).
Hopefully I went through everything, I am pretty sure on this information. If I did make a mistake please correct me anyone.Last edited by Chaldo; 08-31-09 at 11:21 AM.
08-31-09 11:17 AMLike 0 -
I think data speed is a 50/50 situation (50% network, 50% technology). For instance, Sprint and Verizon are both CDMA/EVDO networks, but Sprint's data speeds are way faster than Verizon's.
Here, read this article from BGR: Carrier Wars: Sprint speed test results : Boy Genius Report08-31-09 11:22 AMLike 0
- Forum
- Popular at CrackBerry
- General BlackBerry News, Discussion & Rumors
Which is faster? 1xev or Edge?
LINK TO POST COPIED TO CLIPBOARD