[neil74]

So I've read some threads re poor signal, my issue is slightly different in that I have comparable signal (according to the menu bar) but the Speedtest results are massively different.

My S8+ using the same sim and exact same location in my kitchen was showing H+ rather than 4g and using Speedtest gave results of 13.79 and 14.42. My K1 also showing H+ could manage no better than 5.76, and a couple of attempts were sub 2.00

Not scientific I know but quite the difference.

[John Vieira]

Well, the S8 is many times more powerful as well.

So even if signal strength was perfect on both devices, the S8 would probably perform better.

Not a great comparison unfortunately.

[anon(9742832)]

So I've read some threads re poor signal, my issue is slightly different in that I have comparable signal (according to the menu bar) but the Speedtest results are massively different.

My S8+ using the same sim and exact same location in my kitchen was showing H+ rather than 4g and using Speedtest gave results of 13.79 and 14.42. My K1 also showing H+ could manage no better than 5.76, and a couple of attempts were sub 2.00

Not scientific I know but quite the difference.

My friend has the same issues with his KeyOne. We called AT&T on my Corporate account and found out the may be compatible with the system. But it will not receive system (tower interface) updates. So it may not work 100% with the network.

[neil74]

I wouldn't imagine that processor would have such a huge impact on data speeds? Maybe an edge but nothing that would explain such a gulf?

[neil74]

I'm in the UK btw. On the 3 network.

[PDAJAH]

So I've read some threads re poor signal, my issue is slightly different in that I have comparable signal (according to the menu bar) but the Speedtest results are massively different.

My S8+ using the same sim and exact same location in my kitchen was showing H+ rather than 4g and using Speedtest gave results of 13.79 and 14.42. My K1 also showing H+ could manage no better than 5.76, and a couple of attempts were sub 2.00

Not scientific I know but quite the difference.

I'm in the UK and Vodafone I see no slow down in LTE speed. You may find the K1 does not support some of the LTE bands used by Three. The S8 has great LTE band coverage.

[neil74]

I will do more tests in different locations, my house does have poor signal (1 or 2 bars and h+ rather than 4g) so is maybe a bit of a torture test.

[John Vieira]

I wouldn't imagine that processor would have such a huge impact on data speeds? Maybe an edge but nothing that would explain such a gulf?

The meaning of SOC means system on a chip.

Which means all the major components, including the cellular modem, are part of the SOC.

Some yes, a more modern and more powerful SOC will make a difference.

Part of the reason why the 625 is a poor choice.

Now, it's not the only thing that matters. Antenna design is even more important. But it matters a little too.

[neil74]

Just tested at work on a strong ish 4g signal and it faired much better 30mbs both download and upload. That is comparable to my S8 and as 3 is not as fast over here as EE that is pretty decent.

Will continue to keep an eye. Maybe the K1 is good for 4G but lacking for non-4g?