1. mauro99's Avatar
    which case is better?
    06-22-09 01:24 AM
  2. olah1's Avatar
    I was torn between the Case Mate Barely There and the Incipio and I read a lot of reviews. There were many people who said the Incipio breaks easily but I didn't listen. THIS IS A FACT!! And it's not due to "customer error" from being rough when putting it on or off. I had mine for TWO weeks only. I then contacted Incipio Customer Service including an attached picture of my broken case. Jenna said I could return it for a replacement because there is a warranty but I'd have to pay for the return shipping!! There's no legitimate good company out there that won't pay for return shipping of a DEFECTIVE product, especially within only 2 weeks! She said nothing else could be done. So why would I pay even more money to ship a piece of junk back in order to get a replacement piece of junk and start all over? HORRIBLE CUSTOMER service, NOT the great customer service that I have read about at all! They must have changed their policies or something because I wouldn't buy another case from them if they don't stand behind their products enough to not make the customer pay for a DEFECTIVE item!
    10-28-09 06:44 PM
  3. david9962000's Avatar
    I have had both and I like the Incipio feather better (There is a new generation out) because it's thinner but it's a little tight to take off for battery pull. The Barely there is good too and they both have smooth finish but the edges on the barely there are a little rounded and a little to high. It bothered me when I used the keys on the edges.
    10-28-09 07:09 PM
  4. stevcha's Avatar
    Ive used both and the feather is better in my opinion. The case mate felt cheap to me. I like the overall design and feel of the feather a lot more.
    10-28-09 08:16 PM
LINK TO POST COPIED TO CLIPBOARD