If you have to get one today, I'd get the captivate. I for one have nothing but problems with my captivate but tons of people live it. I've had the streak but that was on launch date. So who knows what its like now.
Otherwise, I'd wait & check out all the 4g phones. They're doing the same thing for me since I've had to go through 6 captivates, 2 torches & half of an HTC surround.
Posted from my CrackBerry at wapforums.crackberry.com