[--TommesJay--]

Let's see about this.

Samsung

Dim displays? Q10.
Gimmicky features? You're right, no BBs have that.
Ugly software? Personal opinion.
Design-wise fragmented software? I don't know what that even means, hence I'll give you that one.

Apple

Sensitive devices. Since when was sensitive bad?
Bad reception. +1 for BB.
Aluminum. Aluminum looks sweet, so -1 for BB.
No file management. +1 for BB.
No saving GIFs as GIFs, even though you can apparently save them as a different, better file type. +1 for BB.

HTC

Shabby photos. I don't know anything about that so I'll give you this one.
Sensitive devices. Still think that's a good thing. I hate using a phone that makes me tap twice to push a button.
Bad reception. Maybe, I'll give you that one.
Bad ergonomics. How?

LG

No update support. I had an update to my mega-cheap LG Optimus One. Went from Android 2.2 to 2.3.
Uninspired hardware design. Personal opinion.

Nokia

Bulky, tanky, heavy hardware. I've never used one very long so can't comment on how it feels, clearly you've used all these phones and know a lot more about them.
Notification center. Personal opinion, Windows Phone has live tiles which give notifications.

Sony

Dim displays. Again, Q10 has a dim display.
Bad viewing angles. Haven't used one so I don't know.
Ergonomically a nightmare. How?

Forgot about the ergonomics of the HTC One. Its size together with the sensor button placement below the display is just bad for one handed use. Secon point are the shape and keystrokes of the other hardware buttons. It's bad.

Posted via CB10