5 reasons NOT to switch to BB10 (followed by: 5 reasons to switch?)
1) Cascades, the main evolution -and most brilliant on small phone screens, is not only useless on PB large screens: it's less efficient. Definitely. For instance, you just can forget multipanes GUIs; similarly, it seems you won't even see the neigboring active apps in this "rear zoom mode" we just always use to switch apps.
So, Cascades are great for phones, and will be a bother on Playbooks. [edit:] following the video posted by pascal95260, there seems to be more to Cascades on the Playbook that just the series of 'curtains' one usually gets on the phones version, so I may well remove this point
2) Blackberry phone screens are high-defs but remain way smaller than ours. Because of that, expect BB10 apps will sport Larrrrge buttons, with Biggg fonts, just wasting space on a Playbook. For more obviousness on that, just go seeing the BB10 screencaptures of file managers, and compare them to the present ones: nuff said.
On Playbooks, BB10 will only look cool to the visual impaired ones.
3) Say farewell to all your sideloaded Android apps. Not only updating the OS will delete them all, chances are old sideloads won't work on BB10 (just like the BB10 bars generally don't work on the present system).
My painfully ported Eye-Fi receiver will certainly die, just crashing my full photo process...
4) Also say goodbye to all initial Playbook apps -the ones that started it all but were then more or less left as is. Any app not updated in 2012, for instance, is an app abandoned by its dev. Indeed these are not so many amont the presently useful -but if one of these happens to be among your niche apps...
5) You'll not reinstall all your 150 apps anyway. Face it -you won't spare the time.
While the boldest of us may turn this into a welcome spring cleaning, still, switching means just twice less apps on your very own machine, day 1.
Now, before you release the hounds, I tried to symetrically find five good reasons to switch. Honest. That was just a bit harder.
1) USB OTG supported. This feature alone cancels all the 'Congress Humiliation syndrome', where an otherwise selfsufficient notetaker/presentation manager/mailreader just leaves you dead in the water when this key new colleague hands you his slides on a stick.
This is an. enormous. change, all the more it is very public
2) Your office VPN may better deal with you. While up to now your IT guys just ignored your arcane tablet, even once you-had-yourself-painfully-uploaded-all-the-PC-certificates-on-the-thing, now they'll have a smartphone executive crowd to deal with: you'll pass along with them (if the company didn't switch to Samsung, that is)
3) As more native apps are blooming at this moment, chances are you'll finally find a proper replacement to this efficient-but-atrociously-black-with-microscopic-fonts ported android app.
4) You'll be allowed to redefine default apps for all filetypes (or at least I hope so). Only these never opening a PDF file here won't rejoice.
Pick 'PDF Reader' app by SporadicSoftware, set as default, done. And just bliss.
5) Cherry on the cake, you may get a real system file picker (is this true?). Something that just allows you to open documents, photos, etc. from within an app
You know, instead of seeing all hundreds of them at the same time (after a 2-mn scan delay), renouncing, going back to learning that filename by heart, now typing it in the search field, and see it crash...
So, what's your take?
Last edited by Herve5; 01-22-13 at 02:12 PM.
- 01-22-13, 09:35 AM #2
I am curious...all of these sound like you are telling people NOT to switch to BB10 based on how it will perform on the Tablet, yet apparently it will work great on a smartphone? So wouldn't that be a great reason to switch to BB10??
Anyways, my next point is this: You seem to have a lot of information on how BB10 will look and perform on the PlayBook...how do you know all of this about BB10 on the tablet? Have you seen it, or just speculating?
As concerns insight, I have nothing else than the enormous number of BB10 posts, not only in the forums aside this one (you even have one dedicated BB10 subforum on Crackberry*) but even here!
But yes indeed, I can tell you I'll definitely NOT be the first one to switch, if I do it. There are things I truly believe will break in my processes...
(*) my link above for file managers lands in it. You have maybe 500 screenshots and as many hands-on analyses there...
- 01-22-13, 10:02 AM #4
"Cascades, the main evolution -and most brilliant on small phone screens, is not only useless on PB large screens: it's less efficient. Definitely. For instance, you just can forget multipanes GUIs; similarly, it seems you won't even see the neigboring active apps in this "rear zoom mode" we just always use to switch apps.
So, Cascades are great for phones, and will be a bother on Playbooks."
How do you know that it will be great for phones and not the PlayBooks? the PlayBook is 7 inches and phone is 4.2inches, thats not a huge difference so why would it be that much worse on the PlayBook? and how do you know that you wont even seen neighbouring active apps on the PB? Also what is the "rear zoom mode"?
Sorry, I respect your decision to not switch to BB10, but before you state all these reasons not to switch, you will need something to backup your claims.
- 01-22-13, 10:05 AM #5
Response to arguments against:
1) I doubt apps will look bad on the PB. Android manages to make one APK look great on any screen size, I'm pretty darn sure BB10 will too.
2) This seems to be practically the same point as 1) to me; Cascades is the app GUI framework, so any problems with it is purely an in-app problem
3) I see no reason for this statement. I have seen nothing to back this up.
4) Again, I have seen nothing to suggest that old apps will stop working. Sure, they won't be installable on new BB10 phones, but it is my understanding that they will continue to work on the PB
5) Due to 3) and 4), I don't this is an issue; I don't believe any apps will be lost by updating
So that's your arguments against debunked, now on to responses to your arguments for:
1) valid comments
2) I don't deal with VPNs, I have no idea if there are issues using one with the PB as it is now; as far as I know, there are VPN options in the PB settings, but I have no experience trying to use them
3) There should be no need to replace any functional app unless there is a superior one released; I certainly have no issues with colours or font sizes in any Android app, sideloaded or installed from App World.
4) Once again, I have seen nothing to back this up. Is there actually any evidence/statement to suggest this to be the case, or are you just spouting random hopeful guesses? If it's true, that's great, but it'd be almost useless without a decent native file manager which brings me to...
5) There have been screenshots of such a file manager (which I was made aware of by a link in your post), so I'd guess it's probably true...and yes, this shall be a fine addition.
So to summarize my post, there is no reason not to upgrade, and plenty of reasons to upgrade.
EDIT: And I agree with mphillips828 when he/she says you need something to backup your claims when you cite all these "reasons".
- 01-22-13, 10:09 AM #6
I don't even think we've even seen Cascades for Playbook yet, everything is done in Air on the Playbook. I think the BB10 is being built as a multi-device, vertical platform, I believe the framework with they've built has to take this extensibility into account (phones, tablets, car infotainment, appliance/pc?).
I think the BB10 today could not have happened without PB OS providing a test bed, stop gap solution. The energy RIM and consumers have invested into the 2 million Playbooks is a small drop if the 10+ million BB10 devices can sway developers into accepting it as relevant ecosystem.
- 01-22-13, 10:38 AM #8
As a little addition to my previous post, I'd just like to say I intend to upgrade to BB10 as soon as I possibly can. If there's a dev beta or anything like that, I will certainly install it. Otherwise, the day I hear it has been released, I will be updating.
- CrackBerry Genius of Geniuses
01-22-13, 11:45 AM #10
- 5,805 Posts
- Sir Glaurung the Great
"My painfully ported Eye-Fi receiver will certainly die, just crashing my full photo process..."
Hey Herve5, do you have a second Playbook? I'm going to keep my second 64gb unit (set up for photography and ALL my CD's and movies are on it plugged into my A/V home system) at the current level
so my EYE-FI WILL STILL WORK. The "work" Playbook will get to upgrde and see how things go.
But this way, I still use my Eye-Fi (and hopefully you) with My Oly E3
- 01-22-13, 12:26 PM #11
3)As for Android bar apps, it would be a dealbreaker: Cannot let my GameboyColor, Mass transit schedule apps, Google Latitude, etc
I would add 6) Bridge feature. Any modification to that would surely prevent me from switching.
B3) It's so painful to search picture to open with a program!
The solution would be to get another one of those great device...they are cheap now...Is there a risk price go up with BB10??
- 01-22-13, 01:39 PM #14
this for instance) so on that one I am definitely confident...
- 01-22-13, 03:58 PM #17
I'm pretty sure if RIM was to release BB10 for the Playbook it would be optimized for it. Based on this assumption I doubt you have wasted screen real estate due to large buttons. Their not just going to put the phone software on the tablet (I hope).
- 01-22-13, 04:49 PM #18
(And as I mentioned before, I have seen absolutely no evidence that any sideloaded apps, Android or native, will be lost in the upgrade)
an example of BB10 backport turning it 'for visually impaired'
Expect all new apps will be like this one:
Dictionary+ : English Dictionary & Thesaurus for BlackBerry PlayBook
This has advantages: for instance, Playbook will be the only tablet you can safely manipulate with your toes
Humor aside, the coming of BB10 will indeed bring lots of new apps to Playbooks, which we wouldn't have got otherwise, and moreover these will be native ones -all in all a very positive point. But... I'll be a bit worried when showing them, this not to speak of the screen surface waste in the GUI...
- 01-24-13, 04:20 AM #20
Like Apple iPad or even Android tablet , we always have different softwares GUI between phones and tablets . In the iPad , sometimes we still see a bad GUI if using iPhone app . It's not only a matter of PB . Software development will make it suitable with your PB when companies think that this is a nessessary movement.
- 01-24-13, 05:58 AM #22
- CrackBerry Addict
01-24-13, 06:31 AM #23
- 557 Posts
Hello Herve5 !
I'm only concerned about the topic. Now that I've read i understand you're talking about the PB, but people at a first glance will think you're talking about the phone and i think it's a little negative.
In another opinion i truly understand how hard it is when you have your device set to work perfectly for you, it's like formatting your computer where you have to re-download, re-install, re-configure, i know, its a nightmare.
- 01-24-13, 09:40 AM #25
I'm failing to connect on your argument against side-loaded Android apps...assuming the 'original' bar files we spent the last year+ converting won't install, we should be able to RE-convert them, and see them run in the same type of Android instance as we do now, no?
- By JNM in forum BlackBerry Bold 9930/9900Replies: 21Last Post: 09-29-11, 11:27 PM
- By Shayan23 in forum BlackBerry Bold 9000Replies: 17Last Post: 10-02-10, 01:46 AM
- By romaromama in forum BlackBerry OS AppsReplies: 6Last Post: 02-06-10, 10:16 AM
- By romaromama in forum General BlackBerry DiscussionReplies: 6Last Post: 02-06-10, 10:16 AM
- By svendster in forum General BlackBerry DiscussionReplies: 10Last Post: 07-12-08, 01:36 PM