View Poll Results: Which PB Case is the Best?
- 53. You may not vote on this poll
OtterBox Defender vs Ballistic Tough Jacket
I need the opinion of Crackberry's finest, which PB case is the best for ultimate protection?
The Ballistic Tough Jacket Series Case which has no screen protection or
The OtterBox Defender Series Case
I like the Ballistic Tough Jacket Look and design especially the corner protection, but it doesn't have screen protection which I think is most important. I like the OtterBox because its perfectly designed especially the button function aspect, but it only comes in one color.
Secondly no matter what case I choose I suspect I may have a problem fitting my PB into my back pocket of my jeans or in the side pocket of a pair of cargo pants. Wonder how many inches these cases will addd to the dimension of the PB?
- CrackBerry Abuser
02-07-12, 12:24 PM #3
- 318 Posts
- pm me if you want it.
I couldn't answer the poll. I have the defender and love it. However the bulk is a pain to deal sometimes. also i've noticed sometimes the screen cover prevents accurate touching. I never used the ballistics, was really hoping someone on here could compare the 2 side by side to get a more accurate review of them.
- 02-07-12, 01:06 PM #4
When I've carried my pb inside its SHIELDED Otterbox inside my daypack for flights or even on an occasional hiking or biking trip, I really like the fact that the screen is protected by the additional shield. I'm not even referring to the "built-in, clear screen protector" but the shield which also works as a stand. I don't have to worry that my camera, gps, ac adapters etc also packed in the daypack for flying will not press on the screen.
The color accents of the other are nice looking but I prefer the real protection. I hope the corner protection on the otterbox is sufficient. I think there was a video of someone frisbee-ing the otterboxed pb.
- 02-07-12, 01:18 PM #5
I have the Otterbox. It does protect well. My 4 yr old son uses my PB alot. Couple of months ago he dropped it off my bed onto the hardwood floor, which granted was only about 3 feet. He got off the bed picked it up and dropped it again while getting back in. After I changed my underwear, I realized it was really protected well. The thing bounced a couple times on each drop. and this was without the extra shield/stand on.
Just my 2 cents...
- 02-07-12, 01:34 PM #6
I have the otterbox. If you like the ballistic case just get it, don't let the not having a screen protector stop you.
I removed the crappy plasticky feeling screen protector from the otterbox I got and replaced it with a regular tablet screen protector, works much better. It is not like the otterbox sp is any more shock proof than a regular nicer feeling sp. Go for the ballistic it looks nice.
- 02-07-12, 01:52 PM #8
The Otterbox is a real good case, so the bulk that it adds is worth the protection. Honestly I didn't like the stand at first but now I love it, it comes in handy when sitting at dining table and no matter what room I take the PB to it sits nicely when listening to the radio. Btw, WOW can you say landslide!!
- CrackBerry Abuser
02-07-12, 03:22 PM #10
- 278 Posts
I've had my Ballistic case for Playbook now for almost a year. It's a fantastic case and much cheaper in price, compared to the Otterbox.
The back panel that has the kickstand acts as a screen protector when not in use, so not sure what you mean by missing screen protection.
I've added a screenguard to the screen, just for added protection when I have the panel off.
It's taken tons of abuse and has protected my Playbook very well, especially in the corners where it has extremely thick silicone material.
I've taken the case off and on numerous times and the fit remains perfect (not stretched).
I would whole-heartedly recommend the Ballistic case based on price-point, quality and ability to protect your Playbook.
I've owned an Otterbox case for my 9700 in the past. I went through 5 warranty claims on the cheaply built holster and finally replaced it with a Seidio case that has never failed me.
Otterbox was a good brand back in the day, but they're quality has waned, in my humble opinion and from my experiences.
Go with the Ballistic case....its cheaply priced and will serve you well!!!
- 02-07-12, 04:07 PM #12
- CrackBerry Addict
02-07-12, 04:14 PM #14
- 573 Posts
Then out of frustration push the rubber in hard and heard it snap further in place.
Jesus now I can take it apart and back together blindfolded.
Have 2 playbooks in otterboxes but might look into the incipio silicrylic case for my third one if I can track down in Canada for a good price.
Got my otterboxes at costco.ca for 43.99 and free shipping cheapest I good find or them.
Last edited by balding1; 02-07-12 at 04:31 PM.
- 02-07-12, 04:14 PM #15
I have the otterbox on my 8 year olds playbook. I love it! It has already taken spills and looks like it did on day one. He even had something agaist the screen that left a nice mark on the screen protector, but I was able to buff it out. Very happy with the purchase
- 02-07-12, 04:31 PM #16
I went with the Otterbox. Both have excellent protection, but in my opinion the Otterbox looks more professional and less bulky. I'm happy with my purchase. I also use Otterbox commuter on my 9650 making them a perfect looking pair
As far as price I found the Ballistic to be higher in price than the OtterBox, unless I'm looking in the wrong place. I found the Ballistics case at Newegg.com for $54 bucks with free shipping. The OtterBox seems to be priced out at $40-$45 bucks plus shipping.
- 02-07-12, 06:10 PM #20
I have the Otterbox on my Playbook, 9900 and 9800. The only problem was with the front piece on the 9800 (and makes them all a bit bulky), otherwise i have been quite happy with the product. The only fear that i had was with over heating with the playbook, but I have not seen any problems of this in the forums and I have not noted any change in performance.
- 02-07-12, 06:11 PM #21
I own the Otterbox , and it has a Peice of plastic that protects the screen on top of the stand also being protection , althought i have never had to take my PB out of the defender case , i am happy knowing that it is snug and protected. the ballistic does not offer a plastic screen protector , it does however have the stand that doubles as a screen cover .
But when its in use the glass is exposed.
As far as fitting it in a cargo pocket , the otterbox case with the cover on does fit in standard cargo pockets , it is a little heavy so i hope you wear a belt.... Can't have you mooning anyone.
Although that ballistic is nicer looking i think the otterbox is a better case overall.
There is only a hand full of otterbox defender cases that aren't that nice , the one for the 9860 isn;t very nice and i am going to have to get mine replaced. however for the playbook its very good.
For all the nay sayers on the otterbox , Look at all the simularities between all the cases of equal protection , they all have a polycarbonate plastic "case" then a rubber cover , and otterbox has been doing this longer than just about everyone else.
- 02-07-12, 07:23 PM #22
First BB 8330 in an Otterbox Defender
Second BB Storm 2 in an Otterbox Defender
Third BB PlayBook in an Otterbox Defender
Forth BB 9860 in an Otterbox Defender.
Do you think I like Otterbox?