In Poynt, if you click on the gas station of interest, and then "See Station Details", it lists the prices for every grade.
I don't know if it got updated since, but just D/L'ed Poynt after seeing this thread, and you can search cheapest prices by grade, don't even need to go into station details...
Poynt is sweet btw! Integrates well with Google Maps app too.
I've been using gasbuddytogo.com for some time now, works great. I hardly ever visit the stations listed, so long as I know the ones nearest me are within a few pennies of the stated lowest prices. I know people who will spend $2.00 worth of gas to save .02 by driving across town, though! lol