Printable View
I love the framework for the BB10 OS thus far, however I feel it could use more jazz. Do you guys feel what we see now will be 90% final? or will we see a even more polished OS on launch day?. With Rim acquiring TAT I hope they have a lot more UI magic to show us :)
I've been saying that for a while....I just hope it is true.
Two more days people.... Two more days... This thread is (forgive me) pointless. There have been many discussions on this topic. If we get more from TAT awesome, if we don't then we dont. But cheers to TAT for the cascades framework. That in itself is all the magic BB10 really needs.
if rim were hoping to compete in the consumer market then I would say yeah they would definitely be adding more polish as it is very bland atm.
but with all the hints about their strategy focusing on enterprise more, i am not so sure. from a business point of view the ui is fine the way it is.
we'll find out soon anyway :)
Sent from my BlackBerry 9810 using Tapatalk
lol what UI does'nt look bland?? its text and background colours you can always read manga,comics you want cool art.Seriously every UI is boring if you want rainbow colours you on the wrong brand.Additionally unless you have a dev device you wont see the rich colours we are just seeing screenshots and video's its all different when its in your hand.
Things that look cool at first are only cool for 5 minutes.This is a tool first the magic is in cascades.This looks very pc'ish to me Im sure when themes become available you can look for non dull skins.2 days that is all.
I think TAT's work was more to build cascades so that developers could use it to build the prettiest applications possible
how much of it is worked into the core OS...we'll see on Wednesday.
i meant the lack of little touches such as animations in between transitions etc.
So you're saying that it's okay to match the competition and there's no need to oe-up them? That's what separates the leaders from the followers.
From a practicle, functioning point of view based on what we've seen of the OS it certainly looks like they innovated and improved on competing OSes out there. It wouldn't have taken much to extend that to the UI. You have to admit they fell short. Let's hope this changes when they unveil the full monty on Wednesday.
Not everything that is designed well has to jump out at you but it could be when you see a subtle mic icon and go "wow" that looks great and I think think that TAT has done a great job of that. You have to remember that RIM probably wanted them to keep it a little safe as well since they have a lot of business clients that orobably would not want all of that "jazz" and that is the problem that I see with WP8. It just seems to consumer focused for enterprises and too me (don't get upset) a little childish. So anyway I think tat has done a great job on the UI of BB10.
As well it seems like they can not do any good because if the UI was too different then people would be complaining and now people are complaining that it is too plain.
Was expecting a BB10 tattoo/
Well there are some. The way the voice assistant glides away when finished, the way files are "shredded" in print to go, the slide between app screens, etc. Considering there is not much that we have seen in terms of a final complete version of the OS, there are glimpses.
There are a million little touches that you would never notice --- like the subtle 3D effects of the Playbook's photo app. There is a subtle 3D effect when you swipe left or right to see all your app icons in BB10 --- not even iOS has that 3D effect.
i have noticed them, the last one is a great example. but it is hardly one of millions, i fear it is one of few so far.
i hope to see more of these in the final software, which i am very much aware is still to be revealed
Ten point one folks ..10.1
Sent from my BlackBerry by Choice using Tapatalk
TAT has shown a bunch of cool concepts for "bland" apps. I stopped watching their demos because it just got frustrating never seeing something put in production. Examples like the music app, the contacts app, the photos app. All of those had "wow" to them that would get attention at a launch and not detract from the usefulness or practical nature of the app. Business people would not use a media app because it had a cool 3D effect carousel to it, or because contacts actually looked like a rolodex. Hopefully there'll be something there on Wednesday. My fear though is that the vast majority of TAT founders left because their creativity was crushed under RIM.
Also adding lots of "jazz" to a UI experience doesn't necessarily make it a better one. If you want a customizable framework with a few rules to follow you can't exactly add things in there that don't add to the experience.
thats true, but the issue is, BB10 isnt the only great os out there. Jazz helps pull it apart from the crowd
Yes, jazz certainly doesn't hurt though, all things being equal.
To keep both crowds happy, they could put an OS/App setting to turn jazz ON or OFF. I think I would only turn on jazz when demoing it to others and keep it turned off at other times :) Probably eats some more battery to leave jazz ON all the time.
They were never meant to be implemented in real life --- because while they are cool to look at for the first 30 seconds, you would want to throw it out after using it for 24 hours. What is the point of tracking your email with a bunch of squiggly lines?
TAT's PAYING customers NEVER wanted those idiotic futuristic UI's that don't work in real life --- just looked at the original Android UI that TAT developed. I remember TAT's website used to boost that they designed hundreds of millions of cell phone UI's --- guess how many are those futuristic looking ones that you see on their videos? NONE.