[Brian.]

So I'm looking at getting this case for my VZW iPhone 4 with the Otterbox Commuter case on it. My question is which 1 do you think will be a better fit the Medium or Large. The iPhone's dimensions with the Commuter case on is 4.73 in x 2.50 in x 0.55 in. The sides on the case are elastic.

The Nite Ize sizes are:

External Case Dimensions:
Small: 4" x 2" x 1"
Medium: 4.5" x 2.5" x 1"
Large: 5.5" x 3" x 1.7"

Which 1 would you guys go with? I don't want the case so tight it takes 2 hands to get out but at the same time I don't want a oversized case with too much room.

I contacted them via email but they could not give me an answer.

[Mike9800]

I would recommend getting the Otterbox Defender case. It comes with a holster and I can basically throw my iPhone down the driveway and pick it up and it works fine. Its a good sturdy case. Its my first case for my phone thats not from siedio and its a dream.