[contender]

So I am debating between these two phones currently, and could use any insights. Currently I have a Curve 8900 with tmobile. I know these phones are on sprint and plan on jumping carriers too.


Samsung Galaxy
Productivity:

* 3G/4G capability
* Samsung 1GHz Cortex A8 Hummingbird Application Processor
* 4-inch Super AMOLED capacitive display with pinch-to-zoom
* Google full HTML browser - bandwidth and quality that rival that of netbooks
* Android 2.1, with access to more than 50,000 apps on Android Market™
* Simultaneous voice and data capability in 4G and Wi-Fi coverage areas, enabling Web surfing and more while talking
* Google™ mobile services including Google Search™, Google Maps™, Google Talk™, Gmail™, YouTube™ , and syncs with Google Calendar™
* Visual voicemail
* Messaging - personal and business email and text messaging, as well as IM through a downloadable Android Market app
* 3G/4G Mobile Hotspot capability - connects up to five Wi-Fi enabled devices
* 4G data speeds (WiMAX) - peak download speeds of more than 10 Mbps; peak upload speeds of 1 Mbps; average download speeds of 3-6 Mbps
* 3G data speeds (EVDO Rev A.) - peak download speeds of up to 3.1 Mbps; peak upload speeds of 1.8 Mbps; average download speeds of 600 kbps-1.4 Mbps

Entertainment:

* Dual camera: 5 MP camera/camcorder with autofocus, Power LED flash and 3x digital zoom for HD video (720p) recording for capture and playback on an HD television and front facing VGA camera for video chat and more
* Qik video application for video chat service and live video sharing
* High-quality video streaming and downloads at 3G and 4G data speeds
* Samsung's exclusive AllShare service to wirelessly share stored music, pictures and HD video to other DLNA (Digital Living Network Alliance) certified™ home electronics, including HDTVs, monitors, digital cameras, printers and more.
* Samsung Social Hub integrates all of the user's social networking services, messages, personal and business email, calendars and contacts, and can display calendar information from portal calendars, such as Google Calendar and social networking services together in one view with two-way synchronization
* Future access to the Samsung Media Hub, a full library of video and literary content powered by some of the biggest names in entertainment
* Media player with 3.5mm stereo headset jack
* Sprint applications including Sprint Football Live, Sprint Navigation Sprint TV®, and NASCAR Sprint Cup MobileSM
* Bluetooth® 2.1 with A2DP Stereo and EDR
* Built-in WiFi®: 802.11 b/g/n
* Digital compass, six-axis motion sensor, proximity sensor, light sensor, GPS
* Expandable memory: 16 GB microSD card included; supports up to 32 GB



HTC Evo

PRODUCTIVITY

* 3G/4G capability
* Qualcomm® Snapdragon™ QSD8650 (1GHz) processor
* 4.3” capacitive display with pinch-to-zoom and tactile feedback However it doesnt have AMOLED
* World-class HTML browser – bandwidth and quality that rival that of netbooks
* Android 2.1, with access to more than 30,000 apps on Android Market
* GoogleTM mobile services including Google SearchTM, Google MapsTM, Google TalkTM, GmailTM, YouTubeTM , and syncs with Google CalendarTM
* Access to Google Goggles™ to search with pictures instead of words
* Sprint Navigation, with turn-by-turn driving directions and 3D maps
* Updated HTC Sense, award-winning user experience, which includes Friend Stream to integrate Facebook, Twitter and more into a single flow of updates
* Visual voicemail
* Messaging – personal and business email, IM and text messaging
* 3G/4G Mobile Hotspot capability – connects up to eight Wi-Fi enabled devices
* 4G data speeds (WiMAX) – peak download speeds of more than 10 Mbps; peak upload speeds of 1 Mbps; average download speeds of 3-6 Mbps.
* 3G data speeds (EVDO Rev A.) – peak download speeds of up to 3.1 Mbps; peak upload speeds of 1.8 Mbps; average download speeds of 600 kbps-1.4 Mbps.

ENTERTAINMENT

* 8MP autofocus camera with dual LED flash and 1.3MP front-facing camera
* High-quality video streaming and downloads at 3G and 4G data speeds
* Capture and share HD-quality video (720p) from your phone
* Output pictures, slides and videos in HD quality (720p) via HDMI cable (sold separately)
* Live video sharing with Qik
* Built-in kickstand for hands-free viewing
* Media player with 3.5mm stereo headset jack
* FM radio and Amazon MP3 store
* Sprint applications including Sprint TV® and NASCAR Sprint Cup Mobile(SM)
* Bluetooth® 2.1 with A2DP Stereo and EDR
* Built-in WiFi®: 802.11 b/g
* Digital compass, G-Sensor, proximity sensor, light sensor, GPS
* Expandable memory: 8GB microSD card included; supports up to 32GB

SPECIFICATIONS:

* Dimensions: 4.8″ x 2.6″ x .5″ (LxWxT)
* Weight: 6 ounces
* Main display: 4.3” WVGA (800×480) 65K colors
* Standard removable 1500mAh Lithium (Li-on) battery
* Memory: 1GB ROM, 512MB RAM


I never owned an Android phone before so I do not know what to expect. Are updates done frequently on these type of devices? I believe froyo 2.2 is going to hit the market soon. I believe both phones will be able to update to it, but i need to know if HTC or Samsung are notorious for updating their devices. Or can we upgrade it ourself if there happens to be leak on the internet?


Black bold = Pros
Red = Cons

Thanks,

[sfjon918]

don't forget sprint 4g service is a extra $10 a month also the evo comes in white and black, the white one has a different screen then the black one... if i was going to sprint i would get the evo 4g but the galaxy s is more pocket friendly then the evo...

[contender]

don't forget sprint 4g service is a extra $10 a month also the evo comes in white and black, the white one has a different screen then the black one... if i was going to sprint i would get the evo 4g but the galaxy s is more pocket friendly then the evo...

thanks for the heads up, I did not know that..

If anyone else is interested in it


As pointed out on xda-developers, there are two versions of the EVO (002 and 003). It appears the 002 models have a Novatel LCD while most of the newer ones feature an Epson LCD, although I’ve seen reports of these being mixed. To check your model just navigate to Settings > About phone > Hardware Information > Hardware version.

[Shermanmanman]

I'm wondering if Sprint is going to charge $10 for 4G on the Galaxy too... If its 4G capable, I wouldn't be surprised.

[contender]

I'm wondering if Sprint is going to charge $10 for 4G on the Galaxy too... If its 4G capable, I wouldn't be surprised.

yeah, they will. I spoke with one of the representative at sprint store and told me they would tag on the 10 dollar charge on it. Even though they dont have 4g coverage in my area (bay area, california)

[chuckh0308]

I wouldn't consider the 5MP camera on the Samsung a "con." I'd almost be willing to bet money that it will take better pictures than the 8MP camera on the HTC.

Personally I think the 4.3" screen on the HTC is too big.

Though I can't speak for these models specifically, I've found Samsung phones to be quite durable and have excellent call quality.

I think you need to go try them out and make the decision, but if it were me I'd probably go with the Sammy. I'd need to go try them out first too though.

[rcurran28]

Galaxy s for sure

[redsoxfan2133]

I got the Evo a few days ago and love it. There's been no issue with battery life, as the phone (which I turn off every night) lasts me over 16 hours before it dies. The phone gets constant use. There's no 4G in my area either (Charleston, SC metro area) but it still has plenty of speed behind it. The extra 10 bucks a month is a little annoying, but what's 10 bucks over 30 days? I waste that on soda or other things in a week!

[Totalimmortal363]

The Sprint Galaxy S is just terrible to look at. So much screen real estate, yet they add a tacky slide out keyboard. Makes it look like a tween texting phone.

[12MaNy]

I wouldn't consider the 5MP camera on the Samsung a "con." I'd almost be willing to bet money that it will take better pictures than the 8MP camera on the HTC.

I seriously f****ng doubt it.

Personally I think the 4.3" screen on the HTC is too big.

Hahahaha! That's like complaining that your d*** is too big.

Though I can't speak for these models specifically, I've found Samsung phones to be quite durable and have excellent call quality.

No touchscreen device is "durable". If you drop a Galaxy S, or an Evo from more than 4 feet up...it's toast. Call quality is usually pretty good on both devices though.

[BBandDROID4Life]

The epic4g has better specs but its a slider which is fail imo. I had a droid so I know what its like to have a slider. I would rather have the evo.

[BBandDROID4Life]

The epic4g has better specs but its a slider which is fail imo. I had a droid so I know what its like to have a slider. I would rather have the evo.

[kassdog]

I hate the fact that sprint got suck with a slider version of the galaxy s. I would love another android on sprint but can't stand the size of the 4g. Just have to wait for the next one I guess.

Posted from my CrackBerry at wapforums.crackberry.com

[Tre Lawrence]

I prefer the EVO... but I also dislike sliders.